PIZZA: City Results

Search Results

Back to Search Options

Rate a pizza? If already registered or just want to use "Guest" then go here: Login

Rate a pizza? Want your own screen name? Then just register here: Register

THESE ARE THE PIZZAS WORTH A SPONTANEOUS LOCAL TRIP.

OUR RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

Caffe Amici Pizzeria Ristorante, 353 Independence Plaza,

NY, Selden

11784, Phone: 631.698.0818
***Rating***: 6 Overall, Crust: 7, Sauce: 7, Cheese: 5
***Review***: 12/5/2009, Comments: This pizza had a very traditional taste which was really good. The sauce was delicious and had an almost sweet aspect to it. The crust snapped at the edge and had dark, almost burnt patches on the bottom which I really liked. The cheese was good but was somewhat lacking. I think that it was a little too thin and not as geaasey as I like it. Overall, I would move it up to best local for me.
***Rater***: Best Pizza Slices, High School: Islip High School, Islip, NY, 1979

Pizza Town, 751 Route 109,

NY, West Babylon

11704, Phone: 631.226.9502
***Rating***: 6 Overall, Crust: 6, Sauce: 8, Cheese: 6
***Review***: 11/14/2006, Comments: This place has been around for a really long time and they know how to make great Pizza.
***Rater***: Best Pizza Slices, High School: Islip High School, Islip, NY, 1979

PUBLIC RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

Townhouse, 9215 s.r. 52,

FL, Hudson

34669, Phone: 727-862-1149
***Rating***: 6 Overall, Crust: 7, Sauce: 6, Cheese: 7
***Review***: 12/20/2009, Comments: voted best on local area yr in and yr out- also the meals are very tasty.
***Rater***: Pizza-Dahut, High School: Hudson High school, Hudson, Fl, 1984

T J's Pizza, 366 Elm St,

ME, Biddeford

04005, Phone: (207) 284-6133&#
***Rating***: 6 Overall, Crust: 5, Sauce: 6, Cheese: 6
***Review***: 11/17/2009, Comments: If you're coming from NY this is going to be the closest thing you'll find to a NY style pizza. The local tradition is to get french fries with the pizza and I totally recomend it!
***Rater***: Crispy, High School: East Islip High School, East Islip, NY, 1997

Caffe Amici Pizzeria Ristorante, 353 Independence Plaza,

NY, Selden

11784, Phone: 631.698.0818
***Rating***: 6 Overall, Crust: 8, Sauce: 7, Cheese: 7
***Review***: 12/5/2009, Comments: Deliceous-o.
***Rater***: Linda, High School: Newfield, Selden, NY, 1976

Sal Anthony's, 980 Middle Country Rd,

NY, Selden

11784, Phone: 631.451.1470
***Rating***: 6 Overall, Crust: 7, Sauce: 7, Cheese: 7
***Review***: 11/10/2009, Comments: Locally, it's the one of the best Pizza's around.
***Rater***: Linda, High School: Newfield, Selden, NY, 1976

THESE ARE THE BEST IN NEIGHBORHOOD PIZZAS.

OUR RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

Goomba Johnny's Pizzaria, 374 Mooney Pond Road,

NY, Farmingville

11738, Phone: 631.736.0722
***Rating***: 5 Overall, Crust: 5, Sauce: 5, Cheese: 7
***Review***: 05/01/2011, Comments: I could tell that they recognized that I was a potential new regular! They were extremely appreciative of my business. The cheese was really great and to the level that you would consider with an "extra cheese" order. The sauce was good but not as flavorful as I would like it. The crust was also pretty good. As usual, I asked for well done but got a sort of medium well done. But I did eat all of the crust too so it was pretty good. Overall this was definately Pizza Nite worthy. I have to try more Farmingville pizza to know if it is the best local pizza.
***Rater***: Best Pizza Slices, High School: Islip High School, Islip, NY, 1979

Mama Lisa Pizza & Restuarant, 1495 Montauk Hwy.,

NY, Mastic

11950, Phone: 631.395.4600
***Rating***: 5 Overall, Crust: 8, Sauce: 5, Cheese: 5
***Review***: 11/25/2009, Comments: I usually have the Pizza plain or with just pepperoni. This had sausauge on it too. The crust was really outstanding! It snapped when you fold it and I just love that! Mixed below the healthy serving of toppings the cheese and sauce were a little hard to judge. I will definately try this pizza again!
***Rater***: Best Pizza Slices, High School: Islip High School, Islip, NY, 1979

Colosseo Pizzeria and Restaurant, Three Roads Shopping Plaza, 1049,

NY, Port Jefferson Station

11776, Phone: 631.928.4972
***Rating***: 5 Overall, Crust: 5, Sauce: 5, Cheese: 7
***Review***: 11/22/2009, Comments: The cheese on this pie was really really good, The sauce was very good but a little sparce. The crust was asked for well done but only snapped at the rim and not down the middle. This pizzaria came very highly recommended and was very good except for the crust dissapointment. I must admit that I got this pizza first thing in the morning and maybe the oven wasn't warmed up all the way. I would like to try it agian. Definately pizza nite worthy. Best local? Only time will tell.
***Rater***: Best Pizza Slices, High School: Islip High School, Islip, NY, 1979

Alfredo's, 134 Route 109,

NY, West Babylon

11704, Phone: 631.321.1199
***Rating***: 5 Overall, Crust: 4, Sauce: 4, Cheese: 6
***Review***: 03/20/2006, Comments: Was ordered to be well-done but was far from it. Sauce was extremely light and therefore hard to judge.
***Rater***: Best Pizza Slices, High School: Islip High School, Islip, NY, 1979

PUBLIC RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

Hungry Howies, 15359 Amberly Drive,

FL, Tampa

33647, Phone: 813-971-8818
***Rating***: 5 Overall, Crust: 7, Sauce: 5, Cheese: 6
***Review***: 11/17/2009, Comments: HUngry Howies at Amberly has a great selection of crusts available: Cajun, garlic butter, butter cheeze, etc. These are all at no extra cost. The dough is made fresh, so it is not frozen like other chain competetors. Cheeze is 100% wisconsin, yet does not neccesarily taste any different than any other cheese. Good with Beer!
***Rater***: Mark, High School: East Islip High School, East Islip, NY, 1991

Gianna's, 2080 Route 112,

NY, Medford

11763, Phone: 631.207.0981
***Rating***: 5 Overall, Crust: 5, Sauce: 4, Cheese: 6
***Review***: 11/15/2009, Comments: The cheese is very good for a cheese lover like myself. Light sauce. The crust ends are pretty thin and may disappoint someone looking forward to crust. The garlic knots are HUGE and quite good. Worth trying.
***Rater***: sdanahy23, High School: West Babylon Senior High, West Babylon, NY, 2004

Colosseo Pizzeria and Restaurant, Three Roads Shopping Plaza, 1049,

NY, Port Jefferson Station

11776, Phone: 631.928.4972
***Rating***: 5 Overall, Crust: 5, Sauce: 5, Cheese: 6
***Review***: 11/22/2009, Comments: Could've used a little more sauce and cheese in my opinion. It was the first pie out for the day and they should have been kicking it.
***Rater***: John, High School: Newfield High School, Selden, NY, 1978

THESE ARE PIZZAS WORTHY OF THE PIZZA NITE HONOR. THEY MAY NOT BE THE BEST IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD BUT THEY ARE SOME COMBINATION OF PRETTY GOOD, PRETTY GOOD PRICE, PRETTY CLOSE AND/OR THEY DELIVER.

OUR RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

PUBLIC RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

THESE ARE THE PIZZAS THAT ARE BARELY TOLERABLE. THEY MAY BE ACCEPTABLE IN SOME AREAS.

OUR RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

PUBLIC RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

THESE ARE THE PIZZAS THAT ARE REALLY BAD ANYWHERE! IT'S HARD TO UNDERSTAND HOW THEY STAY IN BUSINESS.

OUR RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

PUBLIC RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

THESE ARE THE PIZZAS THAT ARE SO BAD THE DESCRIPTION OF HOW BAD THEY ARE IS CENSORED!

OUR RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

PUBLIC RATINGS

ORDER IS BY STATE, CITY, PIZZERIA

Best Pizza Slices Search    8 Slice Paradise    7th Heaven    6,5,4,3,2,1 Slice    Frozen Pizza
Login to Rate Pizza    Register Screen name    Rating System
Boring    Links    Affiliates    Contact Us
Home

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .